Announcement of Jolla phone, joy and sadness

Yesterday, Jolla have done the announcement of their first phone, and got overwhelming support from all over the world. The product is really beautiful and seems to be very intelligently designed. As a Jolla fan since the beginning, I was very pleased by what I have seen, but there were also something else, that makes me uncomfortable.

Joona Petrell demoing the Jolla phone

Joona Petrell demoing the Jolla phone

My other half

The idea behind the other half, that is much more than a simple cover, is really interesting. The phone could get extended in many useful ways. People can add a Xenon flash, a fish-eye lens, an additional battery or a keyboard depending on their needs. As a developer and a heavy texter, I won’t mind exchanging some of the thinness of the phone with a slide out portrait keyboard with additional battery. The fans of the good old N900 might prefer a landscape keyboard though.

But currently, only colored covers has been demoed. I would say that they will still have success. A lot of people on Twitter were asking about in which color the Jolla phone will come out, expecting that they would be like those colorful Lumias. Well, that is not the case, since all Jollas are black. However, the colored covers makes your device really customization, and I felt in love with the black phone and white cover combination.

The phone itself do not feel bad at all. First good point, the battery is removable. The screen is also quite large and bright. Sailfish OS really shined on it, the vivid colors and icons being really pretty. The size of the device bothered me a bit. My personnal thinking is that the size of the Galaxy S2 is acceptable, but not more. However the Jolla is really huge, and I can barely hold it with one hand. Moreover, it seems that there is a lot of space wasted on the top and bottom, and I cannot really understand why it is there. But sailfish OS really shines on large devices. The gesture based OS is very suited for not moving your fingers around all the screen, and you can go back, and select entries from the pulley menus very easily.

Sailfish also packs a lot of new stuff compared to the previous version shown at MWC. The application store is now integrated at the end of the list of applications. Settings app is even more improved, (we had a slight peak of what would be the application settings panel), new beautiful apps appears, like a note taking application, a calendar, a video player that continue to play when minimized. The best application I have seen now is the contacts one. Usual contacts are presented as a list, sometimes with some pinned contacts at the top. That huge list, often accompanied with the impractical and inefficient «fast scroller», could be improved in the UI aspect. In Sailfish it is different. Since it is likely that you would give more attention to your favorite contacts than to the other ones, only the favorites are displayed. At the bottom of them, an grid of all the letters in the alphabet regroups all the other contacts. If you click on one of them, it will reveal all the contacts starting with that letter. Simple, efficient, no need to scroll.

Android apps also worked. Even if they looked out of context (like if a Harmattan application was running on Sailfish), I have not seen anything wrong with them. However the demos of Android applications were brief, and I think that the support might not be totally polished yet.

A great launch party

Andrea and Iekku

Andrea and Iekku

The K Klaus hostel is really a very good looking place. The bar where the event was handled was very nice and cozy. Free food and free alcohol (thanks to Jukka Eklund), nice people (Iekku, Andrea, Jason, Filip, Henri to name a few), and even some tables on which you could deploy your computer or tablet and live tweet / IRC the event. The decoration, with posters related to the «I’m the other half» motto was simple but nice.

Tomi talking about the community

Tomi talking about the community

Marc did really well at the quick demo and call of participation, and even the new CIO, Tomi Pienimäki, who was wearing an awesome pink shirt, did his presentation with energy, despite being less «dynamic» than Marc. We also discussed with several sailors, and most of them were very open, explaining design choices or listening to feedback, and answering questions.

At the end of the party, all the people that were invited even got a nice «I’m the other half» tee-shirt, and a letter signed by Tomi itself.

A pitiless world ?

The world of mobility is pitiless. In one side, there is Apple, once the company that worth the most in the world, and in the other half, Samsung, a company that spends about 400% the budget of Apple in adverts. However, mobility is more than just products and brands. It is a religion, indoctrinating millions of people who became fan-boys. Tech-press is not saved either, since many journalists are either already fan-boys, or are paid to «become» fan-boys. (Of cause, it is a bit reductive, but it happens)

What can Jolla do in that pitiless world ? Well, they have already done pretty impressive things, like a wonderful teasing for the 20th of May, as well as aggregating fans all over the world. On Twitter, there are many local Jolla communities that are represented, like @JollaFr, @JollaIT, or JollaUK to name a few.

The Jolla phone is really a nice product, especially with the awesome Sailfish OS, however, thanks to Samsung, people (especially fan-boys) tend to compare phones only based on the specs. And Samsung is the clear winner of the spec wars, doubling the number of cores in their phone each year.  Most people are disappointed  by the lack of specs provided by Jolla, because only mentioning that it is a dual-core is really not enough. People wanted to know if it was a ST-Ericsson, or a Qualcomm and how much GHz it is clocked.

The second problem is that OS. This year, 4 new OSes appeared, including Samsung’s Tizen and Ubuntu touch. Those two names are very appealing,. Samsung is the mobile phone market leader, that automatically implies that everything related to mobile by Samsung will be a good product. Ubuntu is appealing to geeks, because it is the most used Linux distribution in the world. And having that distribution on a mobile device is the dream of many. Jolla do not have a name, and even if they are doing true GNU Linux, (while Canonical is basing on Android), neither techies, nor geeks nor «normal consumers» cares about it. At least it runs Android, meaning that those people will still be able to run the application they used to run.

There is also people complaining about the lack of information. We don’t know what screen is on the device, if the screen support radio, FM transmitter, low power mode, 41 MPX cameras and  a lot of other features. These questions often comes from (old) Nokia fans, since they are used to Nokia putting a lot of awesomeness into their phones. and the lack of reply only mean one thing to them: lack of communication, like in the old Nokia era. However, it is not the case. They simply did not decided on what to put into that phone. They were here to show that awesome new concept, that is the other half system.

But Jolla is still very weak in the smartphones wars. There is people everywhere complaining about the startup failing to deliver, that the OS is doomed.Tech press don’t care about that small event, that cannot be compared to the big players. Innovation has no more place into the flow of tech information on the Internet, only big names and big numbers. Even inside the Jolla communities, some people are angry, thinking that they should have get more during Jolla love day. However, Jolla is still small, they are moving forward step by step. Revealing the design of the phone, that includes that other half concept is already an important step.

So who is to be blamed ? Jolla for being slow, and failing to create a live stream that could hypnotize all their fans ? Maybe the fans, because they are expecting too much ? The other fan-boys, for protecting religiously their brand and spreading FUD ? Well, I would say that the problem is deeper. That in a world where the quantity of information (and advertisements) is so overwhelming that people do not take time to understand, instead they just follow the crowd. Jolla just wanted to reveal the interesting concept that they created. Instead, fans and tech journalists only wanted the specs, discarding the rest. Jolla bet on innovation and new concepts, but it seems that today, that’s not rewarding anymore.

The Jolla love room, where Marc Dillon was demoing the phone

The Jolla love room, where Marc Dillon was demoing the phone

I think that the Jolla love day was a success. I loved the passion and imagination that was created after that. My Twitter feed got filled with «Solar charger cover» and «Car mode cover» etc. But I feel sad. I just felt sad that even inside our own community, people are divided, spreading FUD, instead of going forward, and building together.

EDIT: Actually JollaFr is still a place (quite) free of trollers and other non-Jolla fanboys that spread FUD, and I’m wrong on writing that in this community people are divided. However I’m really tired of seeing these kind of people fighting in Jolla posts in generic tech websites, and even on TMO. So yeah, I’m wrong about JollaFr 🙂 and I love that community for being so vibrant !


16 thoughts on “Announcement of Jolla phone, joy and sadness

  1. I also was a little bit surprised that Jolla reveal was such a cameral event, but in the end I got it Jolla is small. One good thing thou – there were no tap dancers.

    I also at first was interested in the specs, but then I thought that the most important thing is user experience and that internals are probably good enough to deliver great buttery smooth performance if SailfishOS demoed on N950 was sailing smoothly. Better hardware would mean not only problems with supply chain, but also higher price.

    I guess those not happy should be listened and lessons learnt, but they shouldn’t eclipse great people working on great product. I believe Jolla will go far – I like their spirit, device and software.

  2. It seems to me that a lot of questions that people wanted an answer to were answered but not all in one place. People were eager to hear about the phone specs because that was all they were expecting to find out. The Other Half didn’t really given anyone anything really concrete to work on. It is all wireless? Can it receive power from the device? Does it require a certain hardware connection? Is it more than just NFC? On the hardware side, not knowing what 3G and LTE frequencies it supports can make some people confused and frustrated.

  3. I think most of all people were confused because Jolla (consciously or not) created false impressions of what to expect. They talked a lot along epic sounding lines of “all will be reveiled” and made a big deal about being able to change colors of the back and menus, both of which have been done ages ago. Basically, nothing was reveiled and what was reveiled was talked about in a skewed focus on trivial things.

    They should have focused more on the usability of the OS in terms of “not having to look at the screen to use favorite functions” ( or the ability to actually change the functionality of the device via the back plate and how that’s done. Instead we got the tip to change the colors to match our dresses when we go to parties…

  4. I stand in awe of the amazing work done by such a small team of talented individuals who, from around the globe, have come together to bring the continuation of an idea to fruition.

    Clearly, there is a multitude of people who, in their own way, are showing immense support for the concept of what Jolla brings to the mobile space, even if it doesn’t appear that way at first.

    Individuals may bemoan the lack of hardware information or instant availability (or for that matter, lack of the full pre-order option range for most regions) and certainly some “fan” groups are already making the most strident and consistent noise across social networking services, but i would argue that this too, shows that Jolla have got it right. there is a market and there is demand and there is support.

    As long as it supports my local frequencies, there are no other specs beyond what have already been revealed that I am interested in (this being purely selfish and primarily due to frustration with my N900 not having 850mhz 3g!) the community focus, the design and the great OS and UI have already won me.

    In a world of “now” and instant gratification, many have forgotten that good things come to those who wait.

    But right now, pending the fulfillment of my pre-order, I’ll spend my time thinking up ideas for “The Other Half” of my shiny new Jolla Phone!

  5. Thanks for the post, very enlightening. I have to say that at first, I was expecting indeed more from the announcement but even if I could not follow the #jollaloveday as much as I wanted, I easily get to understand the magic which was there. And so could not resist the pre-order 😉
    Sometimes people do not realize what Jolla, a start-up, is doing with limited resources – and a comparison with Samsung or Apple, Nokia, Sony is NOT relevant.
    And that makes me sad as well: the number of comments from people saying that Jolla has no chance in leading the industry with that phone or at least competing equal to equal with the leaders! As if Jolla could sell more than Samsung flagship! People do not get that Jolla are not stupid people and they want to make profits but not (yet :)) lead the industry with a first phone: 1 million device is already a nice result (probably more would be better!). I am very impressed that Jolla is doing a great phone, a great OS and dealing all those complexities with about 70 people.

    Other reaction I had to face was: the phone will be old-fashioned when released… People have probably that specs race in mind, but forget that functionality is the core of what you want! I do not see the CPU, but I play with the UI!

  6. Excellent article, Jolla is Jolla, not Nokia or Samsung or Apple. Why should they do things the same way, they should do it their way, get their customers and their community.

    Also completely agree on the unnecessary concentration on big numbers and specs. The amount of news nowadays even the journalists and bloggers don’t have time to actually interpret anything to readers and therefore it’s just easier to list specs. Like it’s not important what the specs actually give the customers or buyers. For Jolla it should be the same as Rolls Royce: How many HP does this thing have? Enough.

    Also waiting for my t-shirt and device later in the year 🙂

  7. “Moreover, it seems that there is a lot of space wasted on the top and bottom, and I cannot really understand why it is there.”

    Radio antennas probably. The further those are positioned away from the rest of the electronics (display, SOC etc.), the better the performance.

  8. First, I would really like you to write on to explain what you are feeling there about the french jolla community (I am one of them) instead of writing it here.

    Personaly I don’t care about the specifications because a phone shouldn’t need 8 cores to run smoothly but I would have liked to hear if the hardware was definitive or not, same about the design especially the dimensions and I would have enjoyed to know more about the other half. For example you say the jolla phone is black. It sounds new to me because I thought there will always be a colorful other half.

    According to me the problem is not what was presented, it is great, but it could have been nice to insist more on the fact the community will decide how the phone will be (hardware & software including the other half) and that many things can/will still change. It would make people stop asking about specifications as they would know it will change.

    • Hello al !
      Well, I think I will soon change that article (or add a disclaimer), because even if there were some trolls, it is actually a good place, with constructive criticism, contrary to other blogs and tech websites.

      • I don’t know if you can or not but maybe you should write an article precising the aim of the jolla love day. I think most of the people knowing you were there and reading you are waiting for more information. It would be enough to share your enthousiasm there as you did it here 🙂

        By the way, I am happy to read you.

  9. Good if Jolla could concentrate on things like:
    Freedom of choice – You’re not restricted to using it a specific way (e.g. Operator customisations, App Market lock-in, similar)
    Intuitiveness of the OS – gestures – videos of it being used
    Efficiency of the OS – doesn’t need 4 cores to run buttery smooth
    Battery savings that result from the better OS efficiency
    Android App compatible
    Demo videos of how well it all runs
    They would get more App Devs onboard IF they would release (non-supported) Sailfish for N9 and N900

  10. Pingback: Smartphone Jolla lançado : sua outra metade « Roberto Colistete Jr.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s